Metaphorical Writing: Harnessing the Power of Metaphor as a Literary Device and Narrative Structure
Metaphor is a powerful and versatile tool in creative writing, enabling writers to communicate complex ideas, emotions, and experiences in ways that resonate deeply with readers. While often thought of as a literary device—a figure of speech that compares one thing to another—it can also be used as an overarching structural element that shapes the entire narrative. A good metaphor enhances clarity without making the writing overly complicated, thereby enriching the prose with vivid imagery and emotional resonance. So, how does metaphor operate as both a literary device and as an overarching structure in creative writing?
What is a Metaphor?
At its core, a metaphor is a comparison between two unlike things that have something in common. Metaphors are commonly used in everyday language, illustrating that many people utilise them subconsciously in regular communication. Unlike a simile, which uses “like” or “as” to draw a comparison (e.g., “as brave as a lion”), a metaphor asserts that one thing is another, thus suggesting a deeper or more symbolic connection (e.g., “Time is a thief”). The power of metaphors lies in their ability to convey abstract ideas in concrete terms, offering readers a richer understanding of the subject matter.
For instance, when William Shakespeare writes in As You Like It that “All the world’s a stage,” he uses a metaphor to suggest that life itself is a performance. This comparison allows readers to contemplate the human experience in terms of acting, roles, and the inevitable progression of life—ideas that might otherwise be difficult to articulate directly.
Metaphor as a Literary Device in Creative Writing
Metaphor as a literary device can be used for a variety of purposes in creative writing. Dead metaphors, such as ‘the paper was white as snow,’ are phrases that have become clichés due to overuse, losing their impact and creativity. Let’s examine how it enhances language, character development, and thematic depth.
1. Creating Vivid Imagery
One of the primary functions of metaphor is to create vivid, evocative images that engage the reader’s senses and emotions. By comparing something abstract or unfamiliar to something more tangible, metaphors make abstract concepts easier to grasp. For example, in Moby-Dick, Herman Melville famously describes the sea as “a vast, uncharted wilderness.” This metaphor transforms the sea from a mere body of water into an intimidating, unexplored realm full of danger and mystery. By invoking the idea of wilderness, Melville underscores the enormity and uncertainty of the sea, heightening the sense of peril that the characters face.
Metaphors can also be used to juxtapose the familiar with the unknown, enabling writers to introduce novel ideas. For instance, a metaphor like “Her laughter was a burst of sunlight on a stormy day” doesn’t just tell us that someone is happy, it conveys an emotional texture—her laughter brings warmth and clarity in the midst of confusion or despair. Writing metaphors is crucial for creating vivid imagery, and avoiding clichés by rejecting initial thoughts can lead to fresh and unexpected comparisons.
2. Revealing Character Psyche
Metaphors can serve as windows into a character’s inner world, revealing their thoughts, fears, desires, and motivations. They give voice to abstract emotions in ways that feel more immediate and personal. In Sylvia Plath’s The Bell Jar, the protagonist Esther Greenwood often describes herself in metaphoric terms. At one point, she refers to herself as being “stuck in the bell jar,” a metaphor that captures the suffocating, isolating feeling of depression. This metaphor conveys not just her emotional state but also her sense of entrapment, making her mental struggle something that readers can empathise with.
Similarly, a character might describe their ambitions as a “mountain to climb” or their failures as “heavy chains,” illustrating the ways in which their struggles shape their identity and experience of the world. Through metaphor, the writer taps into the subconscious world of the character, giving the reader access to their emotional and psychological landscape.
3. Adding Layered Meaning with Implied Metaphor
Metaphors also allow for layered, nuanced meanings that invite the reader to interpret the work on multiple levels. They allow writers to embed symbolism and create resonance. Consider The Great Gatsby, in which the green light across the bay represents Gatsby’s unattainable dream, but it is also a symbol of hope, longing, and the American Dream itself. The metaphor of the green light functions on a symbolic level, representing the pursuit of an ideal, but also evokes the personal disappointment of Gatsby’s journey. Using multiple metaphors can add even more layered meaning, as seen in Medium’s innovative use of metaphorical terms related to performance.
Metaphors can also allow for an economy of language. Rather than describing a situation in long-winded, literal terms, a metaphor can encapsulate a complex idea in just a few words. A metaphor can convey not only what is being described but also how it is perceived or felt. In this way, it condenses emotion, thought, and even history into a single image or comparison.
4. Creating Emotional Resonance
Metaphors often work to evoke a specific emotional response from the reader. By tapping into universal themes—such as love, loss, or conflict—they create connections that transcend the specifics of the narrative. In Romeo and Juliet, Shakespeare uses metaphors to convey the intensity and tragedy of young love. Juliet describes Romeo as “the god of my idolatry,” placing him on a pedestal and suggesting that her love for him is as divine as it is consuming. This metaphor makes the passion of their love more immediate, portraying it not just as romantic affection but as something almost sacred and all-consuming.
Metaphors also have the power to surprise or shock, creating an emotional jolt. A character might describe an emotional or physical experience in terms that catch the reader off guard, forcing them to rethink how they perceive the situation. In this way, metaphor can challenge the reader’s expectations, making the narrative more compelling.
Metaphor as a Sustained Metaphor Overarching Structure
While metaphor is commonly used as a literary device within a single passage or scene, it can also function as an overarching structure that shapes the entire narrative. Metaphors play a significant role in design and communication, helping to convey complex concepts effectively and enhancing clarity and creativity. In this capacity, metaphor provides the framework for the story, offering an underlying thematic structure that drives the plot and defines the characters’ journeys.
Thematic Framework
An overarching metaphor provides a thematic structure that infuses the entire narrative with meaning. In George Orwell’s Animal Farm, the farm itself is a metaphor for a totalitarian state. The animals’ rebellion against the human farmer represents the overthrow of a corrupt government, while the rise of Napoleon and the pigs reflects the dangers of power and corruption. The farm serves as both a literal setting and a metaphorical representation of political systems, and the entire narrative is shaped by this metaphor.
In The Lord of the Flies by William Golding, the island becomes a metaphor for the breakdown of civilization and the descent into savagery. The island is initially depicted as a paradise, but over time, it becomes a symbolic representation of the darker aspects of human nature. This overarching metaphor informs the characters’ actions and the novel’s central themes about human nature, society, and the loss of innocence.
The Hero’s Journey as a Metaphor
Many works of creative fiction follow the structure of the Hero’s Journey, a narrative arc first outlined by mythologist Joseph Campbell. This structure is itself a metaphor for personal transformation, with the protagonist facing trials, learning lessons, and emerging transformed. The metaphor of the Hero’s Journey can apply to a wide range of stories, from ancient myths to modern fantasy novels.
For instance, in J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings, Frodo’s journey to destroy the One Ring is not just a physical journey through Middle-earth—it is a metaphor for the internal struggles of courage, morality, and temptation. The landscape itself becomes part of the metaphor: the lush Shire represents innocence, Rivendell embodies wisdom, and Mordor symbolises corruption and moral decay.
The Metaphor of a Character’s Life
Some writers build their entire narrative around the metaphor of a character’s life as a journey, a struggle, or a transformation. A good example of this is Franz Kafka’s The Metamorphosis, in which the protagonist, Gregor Samsa, wakes up one morning to find himself transformed into a giant insect. While the literal story is absurd and surreal, the metaphor of Gregor’s transformation represents the alienation and dehumanization he experiences in his life—both within his family and society. The metaphor of the physical transformation is intricately tied to Gregor’s inner state, and the novel as a whole can be understood as a reflection on the human condition.
Similarly, in Virginia Woolf’s Mrs. Dalloway, the metaphor of time, memory, and death underpins the narrative structure. The novel takes place in the span of a single day, but its nonlinear structure and focus on internal thoughts evoke the fluidity of time and consciousness. The metaphor of time runs through the narrative as characters reflect on their pasts, question their present lives, and face the inevitability of death.
The Metaphor of the World
In some works, the entire world or setting of the narrative functions as a metaphor for a central theme or concept. In 1984 by George Orwell, the dystopian society is a metaphor for totalitarianism, surveillance, and the loss of individual freedom. The oppressive state, the ubiquitous surveillance, and the manipulation of truth all come together to create a metaphor for the psychological and social impact of totalitarian regimes. This overarching metaphor shapes the entire narrative and guides the reader’s understanding of Winston Smith’s struggle.
In Cormac McCarthy’s The Road, the post-apocalyptic world becomes a metaphor for human survival, the loss of hope, and the enduring love between father and son. The barren landscape, ravaged by an unspecified catastrophe, reflects the emotional desolation the characters feel as they move through the world. This bleak setting is not merely a backdrop but a central metaphor for the internal journey of the protagonists.
Writing Prompts
Here are several writing prompts that can help spark metaphorical thinking and encourage you to explore deeper meanings through metaphor:
1. The Garden of Your Mind: Write a description of your thoughts and emotions as if they were a garden. What types of plants or flowers grow there? Are there weeds you must constantly remove, or do certain flowers represent your joy or sorrow? How does the weather in your garden change with your mood?
2. A Ship Lost at Sea: Imagine a person who feels lost in life. Write about their emotional state as if they were a ship drifting on the vast, empty sea. What does the ocean represent—fear, uncertainty, or freedom? How does the ship weather the storm or navigate through the calm?
3. The Clock of Life: Write about a day in the life of someone using the metaphor of a clock. How do different events represent the ticking of the clock? Do moments of happiness feel like fast-forwarding, while sadness feels like the hands of the clock creeping slowly?
4. The Storm Inside: Think of a time when you felt emotionally overwhelmed—perhaps during a stressful situation or a period of inner conflict. Describe this time using a metaphor of a storm. What is the weather like (a thunderstorm, a tornado, an endless drizzle)? What objects or people are caught in the storm? How does the storm eventually pass or leave lasting damage?
5. The Prison of the Mind: Write about a character who feels trapped in their own mind, as if they are imprisoned. How does the “cell” look? What do the walls represent—fears, doubts, or external pressures? What is the key to unlocking the cell, and what kind of freedom does the character yearn for?
6. The Mirror of Identity: Imagine a character standing in front of a mirror that reflects not just their physical appearance but their identity and self-image. What is reflected back at them? Is it the true version of themselves, or does the mirror distort their self-perception? What metaphors can you use to describe how they see themselves versus how others see them?
7. The Lantern in the Dark: Think about hope, guidance, or wisdom as a lantern in a dark forest. Write a story about a character searching for this lantern. What does the light represent? What obstacles do they face in trying to find it? Is the light always clear, or does it flicker and go out at times?
8. The Battlefield of Your Mind: Write about an internal struggle or conflict you are facing as a battle on a battlefield. Who are your enemies—doubts, fears, or external pressures? What weapons do you use to fight, and what does victory look like? Is the war ever truly won, or is it a constant battle?
9. The Library of Knowledge: Imagine a vast library that contains all the knowledge you’ve accumulated over your life. Each book represents a lesson or experience. How is the library organized? Are there books that are worn and well-read, or others that you’ve avoided opening? What books might you add in the future?
10. The Mask You Wear: Write about a character who wears a mask, both figuratively and literally. The mask hides their true emotions or identity. What does the mask look like? What is it made of—fear, pride, insecurity? What happens when the mask starts to slip or is removed?
11. The Chessboard of Life: Use the metaphor of a chessboard to write about the decisions in life. Each move represents a choice or action, and every decision has consequences. What pieces are you controlling, and which ones are moving on their own? What is your ultimate goal in this game?
Each of these prompts invites you to think metaphorically, encouraging creativity and deeper insight into your emotional and psychological world. Whether you focus on personal experiences, abstract concepts, or fictional scenarios, metaphors can offer powerful tools for exploring complex ideas in a way that is both engaging and thought-provoking.
Metaphor is one of the most powerful tools in creative writing, offering writers a way to express complex ideas, emotions, and themes in a form that resonates with readers. As a literary device, metaphor enhances the richness of the text, from creating vivid imagery to revealing a character’s inner world and adding emotional resonance. When used as an overarching structural element, metaphor can shape the entire narrative, providing a thematic framework that deepens the meaning of the story.
Whether used to describe the struggles of a character, represent the larger themes of a narrative, or create a world filled with symbolic meaning, metaphor adds depth and complexity to creative writing. Writers who learn to wield metaphor effectively can engage their readers in new and exciting ways, inviting them to see the world through fresh, imaginative lenses. Through metaphor, the writer transcends the limitations of literal language and taps into the power of imagination and symbolism, creating works that resonate on a deeper, more profound level.
Are you searching for a course to help you with your writing? Take a look at our new courses here!
