Gladiator 2: Writing Historical Fiction

When it was announced that Irish actor Paul Mescal would be joining the cast of Gladiator 2, the news sent ripples of excitement through both cinephiles and casual moviegoers alike. Known for his raw, emotive performances in Normal People and Aftersun, Mescal’s casting as the lead in Ridley Scott’s highly anticipated sequel to his 2000 epic Gladiator offers a compelling narrative twist. Not only does Mescal bring a fresh face to the role of a gladiator, but his involvement invites audiences to re-examine how historical fiction, especially in the realm of film, can be reimagined through a new generation of actors and filmmakers.

So, how has historical fiction evolved in cinema? And how can writers draw inspiration from such films to craft their own stories? Historical fiction is a powerful tool for both preserving and reinterpreting the past, and by blending fact with imagination, writers can transport audiences to different times and places while maintaining a sense of relevance to the modern world.

Paul Mescal as the New Gladiator: A Fresh Face for a Legendary Role

The first Gladiator film, released in 2000, remains a cultural touchstone in both historical fiction and epic filmmaking. Directed by Ridley Scott and starring Russell Crowe as the vengeful yet noble Maximus Decimus Meridius, Gladiator was lauded for its stirring performances, breath-taking visuals, and gritty portrayal of ancient Rome. The film went on to win five Academy Awards, including Best Picture and Best Actor for Crowe, and forever changed how we view historical epics in Hollywood.

Now, nearly a quarter of a century later, Gladiator 2 is in the works, and Paul Mescal’s casting is one of the most intriguing aspects of the film. Mescal is not your typical action hero. With his chiselled good looks and delicate sensibility, he defies the traditional mold of a muscle-bound, grizzled warrior, like the one Crowe portrayed in the original. Instead, Mescal brings a depth of emotion and vulnerability to his characters—qualities that suggest his gladiator will not be a mere symbol of brute strength, but a fully realized human being, navigating the complexities of violence, survival, and ambition.

This shift in casting signals a broader transformation in the way we approach historical figures and characters in film. Modern audiences increasingly demand characters who feel more human, more nuanced, and less like caricatures. Mescal, with his naturalistic style of acting, may provide just the kind of emotional depth that will define this new gladiator. Where Crowe’s Maximus was driven by revenge and duty, Mescal’s character could be motivated by internal conflict, personal trauma, or even a desire for redemption. The gladiator of today could be a mirror to the complexities of the modern world—a person who is more than just a vessel for physical prowess.

How Historical Fiction Has Evolved in Cinema

Historical fiction has long been a popular genre in literature and cinema, offering audiences a window into times gone by. In films like Ben-Hur, Spartacus, and The Ten Commandments, ancient history was often portrayed through the lens of spectacle. These films were designed to entertain and inform, but they were also rooted in the ideologies of their time, often simplifying complex historical events for mass consumption. Characters were depicted as archetypes: the virtuous hero, the evil villain, the loyal sidekick. These stories often lacked the emotional depth and complexity we would expect from modern narratives.

In the 21st century, however, filmmakers and writers have begun to take a more nuanced approach to historical fiction. Movies like 300, Troy, and Gladiator have attempted to capture the brutality of ancient warfare and the politics of empire-building, but with a level of sophistication that allows for moral ambiguity and more human characters.

The key to creating historical fiction today lies in the balance between historical accuracy and artistic freedom. Filmmakers and writers must navigate the fine line between staying true to the facts of the past and creating compelling stories that resonate with modern audiences. One of the strengths of historical fiction is that it allows for exploration of themes that transcend time, such as power, betrayal, love, and revenge. It offers writers and filmmakers the ability to interrogate historical events through a contemporary lens, raising questions about how the past still influences the present.

For example, Gladiator 2 will likely draw on both the historical realities of Ancient Rome and the imaginative spirit of fiction to create a world that feels both grounded in history and vibrant with possibility. The tensions between historical truth and artistic license are what give films like Gladiator their enduring appeal.

Writing Our Own Historical Fiction: Lessons from the Gladiator Genre

Historical fiction, whether in film or literature, can be a powerful way to explore the human condition. Writers looking to craft their own historical narratives can learn several key lessons from the genre’s evolution and from films like Gladiator.

Start with Research, But Embrace Creative License

The first step in writing historical fiction is, of course, research. This is essential for grounding the story in the reality of the time period you are exploring. However, as any writer of historical fiction will tell you, history is not just a set of facts—it is a web of complex stories, perspectives, and interpretations. Understanding the context of your chosen period is essential, but so too is embracing the creative freedom to reimagine the past.

Films like Gladiator take liberties with historical facts for dramatic effect. While the character of Maximus is fictional, many of the political figures in the film, such as Commodus, are drawn from real history. However, the film takes creative license with their personalities and actions. Similarly, in writing historical fiction, you can play with history to emphasise themes, create suspense, or explore contemporary issues that resonate with today’s audiences. History may inform your story, but it should not confine it.

Humanise Your Characters

One of the reasons Gladiator was so successful was its ability to humanize the characters. Maximus is not just a gladiator; he is a father, a husband, a soldier, and a man driven by grief and revenge. His humanity is what makes him relatable, even in the extreme circumstances of ancient Rome.

When writing historical fiction, think about the emotions, motivations, and internal conflicts of your characters. What would a gladiator really feel like as he faces battle after battle? What would drive someone to seek vengeance or fight for survival in an unforgiving world? These questions will lead you to characters who feel real and who reflect the complexities of the human experience.

Set the Scene with Vivid Detail

The setting of a historical fiction piece is almost as important as the characters themselves. Whether you are writing about Ancient Rome or medieval Europe, the time period should feel tangible, alive, and rich with detail. Descriptions of architecture, clothing, food, and customs can immerse the reader in the world you are creating. But remember, historical fiction is not just about evoking the past through physical details—it’s about capturing the essence of the time and how it shaped the characters within it.

Balance Action with Reflection

In action-packed historical genres like the gladiator film, the stakes are often high, and the battles intense. However, some of the most powerful moments in historical fiction come in quieter scenes of reflection. Gladiators may fight in the arena, but they also spend time contemplating their past, their future, and their place in the world. Balancing moments of intense action with introspective moments allows the audience (or reader) to connect with the characters on a deeper level.

Tackle Universal Themes

While historical fiction is rooted in a particular time and place, the themes explored are often universal. Love, betrayal, power, revenge, and ambition transcend eras. Even a gladiator fighting in ancient Rome can serve as a metaphor for broader human struggles. Writers should think about how the themes they are exploring connect with the audience’s current experiences. What can we learn from ancient Rome that speaks to our own political or social landscape? How do the struggles of a gladiator mirror the challenges we face today?

Gladiators and the Power of Historical Fiction

Paul Mescal’s casting as the new gladiator in Gladiator 2 signals a shift in how we view historical narratives. By bringing a more nuanced, emotional portrayal to the role, Mescal offers a glimpse into a future where historical fiction is defined by its complex characters and its ability to speak to the present. As writers, we can draw inspiration from this evolution, embracing both the rich historical context and the emotional depth of our characters to create stories that resonate across time.

Whether in film or literature, historical fiction offers us the chance to revisit the past, reimagine it, and learn from it. By blending research with imagination, humanising our characters, and exploring universal themes, we can create stories that speak to both the past and the present, ensuring that history is not just remembered, but felt. And who knows—perhaps our own characters will one day stand in the arena, facing their own battles, fighting not just for survival, but for something much greater.

Ready to get started on your own historical fiction narrative? Take a look at our new courses now!